The Third Inning Program in MLB The Show 25 mlb the show stubspresents players with the opportunity to choose from three distinct Boss cards: Trevor Story, Bernie Williams, and Devin Williams. Each offers unique strengths, catering to different team needs and playstyles.
Trevor Story
As a shortstop, Story provides a balanced mix of offensive power and defensive reliability. His ability to hit for both average and power, combined with his strong arm and quick reflexes in the field, makes him a versatile option for players seeking a well-rounded infielder.
Bernie Williams
Williams offers a potent combination of offensive prowess and defensive skills. His ability to hit for average and power, coupled with his speed on the bases and range in the outfield, makes him a dynamic presence both at the plate and in the field.
Devin Williams
For players looking to strengthen their bullpen, Devin Williams presents an elite pitching option. His devastating screwball and high strikeout potential, combined with his exceptional pitching attributes, make him a formidable presence in late-game situations.
Conclusion
The choice between Trevor Story, Bernie Williams, and Devin Williams depends on the specific needs of your Diamond Dynasty roster and your preferred playstyle. Each card represents a top-tier option, but they serve vastly different roles on the field. Let’s break it down further to help you make the best decision.
Ideal Use Case Scenarios
If Your Lineup Lacks a Strong Middle Infielder:
Trevor Story should be your go-to pick. The shortstop position is one of the most important in both real-life baseball and Diamond Dynasty. Having someone who can hit for power, turn double plays reliably, and steal a few bases when needed can be the difference between winning and losing close games. Story’s arm strength and reaction time are particularly valuable in Ranked Seasons where defense can often make or break a team.
If You’re Building Around Offensive Firepower and Need a Cornerstone Bat:
Bernie Williams is your man. He doesn’t just hit — he hits clutch. With high vision, plate discipline, and contact attributes across the board, he’s especially lethal in late-game situations or pressure-packed at-bats. His switch-hitting nature (if implemented in this version, as it sometimes varies) also gives him an edge, letting you maintain favorable matchups throughout a nine-inning game.
Defensively, he’s no slouch either. While he won’t necessarily rival the elite outfield arms like Ichiro or Clemente, his positioning and fielding stats make him dependable in center field. If your team already has solid infield and pitching coverage but lacks an all-around bat who can also flash the leather, Williams is a wise choice.
If You’re Focused on Locking Down Late Innings and Need Bullpen Dominance:
Devin Williams is probably the smartest tactical decision. His screwball is absolutely devastating — a rare and unconventional pitch that MLB The Show players consistently struggle to hit. Coupled with a high K/9 and low H/9, he’s perfect for closing out nail-biters or shutting down rallies in the 7th and 8th innings.
What makes Williams truly unique is his ability to change the pace of a game. If you’re facing a skilled opponent who is zoning in on fastballs and sliders, Williams’ mix of a deadly screwball and deceptive cutter can completely alter their timing.
